Where do I begin? As soon as the tour began, the tour guide mentioned that if we wanted to leave, we should let her know, so she does not assume we are lost. This implied that people had been leaving her tour without notice, which started things off rough. Throughout the tour, the tour guide droned on and on, but did not make the communication very fun, funny, or interactive.
The tour highlights prominent places, people, and works of art from African American, Puerto Rican, Indigenous, Satmar Jewish, as well as other communities, however, the tour guide does not appear super knowledgeable about any of these groups. In fact, she spoke positively about "cleaning up" gang violence, gentrification, and police/government activity that oppresses these groups. Everyone deserves a safe place to live, sure, but the language that was used to describe the progression of the boroughs over time was antiquated and quite frankly, racist. Another oddly placed comment was about a congresswoman from one of the boroughs who essentially pulled herself up by her bootstraps to make it out of New York. We know that "bootstrapping" is a myth that has long been told to further oppress people. There was little attention given to the musical and hip-hop artists that are celebrated in these communities. It would be great to hear more about their careers, where they grew up, how they give back, etc., etc. There was no information given about the Apollo Theatre and what it meant to Black folks in its prime. Additionally, there were some "facts" presented that just were not true. For example, "New York City was a city since colonization." Not quite - much of what is now Manhattan was farmland for a while...
There was no mention, let alone honoring of the indigenous communities that were driven off of their homelands. I would suggest reading up on the history of each stop on the tour, each borough, and the communities that led to the areas becoming what they are today.
It also would have been great to walk around Brooklyn together, seeing the street art and knowing how to contribute to the artists and/or community.
When we saw the Hasidic Jewish community, the narration felt weird. It was as if we were watching them "in their natural habitat" while the tour guide talked about them in very broad generalizations. It reminded me of Ota Benga being put on display in the Bronx Zoo. Disgusting.
The tour guide did not do a great job of ensuring people in the back of the bus knew where to go at each stop, as she did not walk with us. I think it would be helpful for her to walk with a colored umbrella or something of that nature to ensure everyone knows where to go. She was not helpful with photos or even making sure that everyone saw the sights we were stopped at.
The bus was also very old. It was clean and the seats were okay, but it rattled LOUDLY the entire ride. The bathroom on the bus was inoperable and also obstructed the view for people in the back row. The driver and guide did not offer water bottles or ponchos for us, as other tours often do. Also, every seat was sold out, so not all groups could sit together. One party chose to leave the tour before it began. Lastly, this tour does not drop you back at your starting location. You have to take the subway back to Manhattan or walk for an hour. This should be made VERY clear during booking.
Overall, the stop themselves were awesome, despite not having a lot of context for why we were stopping or how the different stops were connected to one another. If you feel like being your own tour guide, you can look up the history of each location yourself and enjoy the stops. However, I don't believe this is what I paid for here.
TL, DR: If you are a person from a historically oppressed group or a person who enjoys ACTUAL FACTUAL history, this might not be the tour for you.